The Peter Norman Alternative

Peter NormanvsRare Carat

Rare Carat is an online diamond business based in New York. It began in 2016 as a price-comparison search engine and has since grown into a direct-to-consumer seller, with customers buying through its platform.

Talk to us today

Peter Norman vs Rare Carat Comparison

	Peter Norman	Rare Carat
Own ring design possible?		(Limited Options)
Online Consulting?
Has a celebrity clientele?
Excellent Reviews?	5 Star Average	5 Star Average
Wholesale Pricing for Diamonds?
Truly Custom or only Customized?
OK to bring own gemstones?
Natural mined and lab grown diamonds?
Best in Class After Sale Service

Why choose

Peter Norman?

Peter Norman offers an unmatched personal touch to engagement ring design, providing unique, one-of-a-kind pieces. If you’re looking for an original design that reflects your taste, Peter Norman’s 5-star rated services ensure quality craftsmanship and customization at a wholesale price. If buying a unique, hand crafted one of a kind engagement ring is your goal, with diamonds at wholesale prices, then Peter Norman might be for you.

When might Rare Carat

be a good option?

Rare Carat is a reasonable starting point when your priority is pricing transparency on a certified loose diamond and you are comfortable buying online. Their deal-scoring tool and free gemologist chat are genuinely useful for understanding whether a specific stone’s price is in line with the market before you commit. If you know the exact specifications you want, do not need a one-of-a-kind setting, and have no stone to bring in, Rare Carat lets you compare certified diamonds with independent grading support at no added cost.

Comparison Details - Peter Norman vs Rare Carat

Build a ring option

Peter Norman

Every Peter Norman ring is crafted as a unique piece, guided by a personal design consultation to ensure that the final product perfectly matches the client’s vision.

Rare Carat

Rare Carat pairs a diamond chosen on its platform with a selection of preset and semi-custom settings, and depending on complexity may accommodate some custom work, occasionally with outside designers. The process runs entirely online: there is no in-studio design session, no wax model to review, and no chance to handle the ring before it is made. If the setting you picture is not represented in their catalog, your options narrow quickly. Peter Norman starts every ring from a blank page.

Online Consulting

Peter Norman

Provides both online and in-store consultations with experts to guide custom design decisions.

Enquire Now

Peter Norman is LA's most celebrated custom jeweler.

Always unique, never customized.

Rare Carat

Rare Carat provides free live-chat access to graduate gemologists who are not on commission. They can help you evaluate a specific stone, read a grading report, and flag clarity or cut issues before you buy, with no appointment needed. It is a solid service for online diamond education. Peter Norman offers online and in-person consultations for clients who want to discuss a design in detail or see stones in person before deciding.

Has a celebrity clientele?

Peter Norman

Has a rich history of celebrity clients, including members of the British Royalty (traditional and rock and roll versions!) and well-known American personalities.

Rare Carat

Rare Carat does not publicize a celebrity clientele and does not operate in the custom red-carpet market; its model is built for volume across a broad consumer base rather than high-profile individual commissions. Peter Norman has designed pieces for celebrity clients and offers the discreet, relationship-based service that custom work at that level requires.

Excellent Reviews?

Peter Norman

With a 5-star average rating across all platforms, Peter Norman’s services are highly recommended for those seeking custom, quality jewelry.

Rare Carat

Rare Carat carries strong customer reviews, reporting thousands of combined Trustpilot and Google reviews with a very high five-star rate and consistent recognition as a top-rated online jewelry destination. Those reviews largely reflect a smooth online buying process, stone quality and responsive service. Peter Norman’s reviews are similarly high, with the emphasis on personal service and the design experience rather than a transactional purchase.

Diamonds at Wholesale Prices

Peter Norman

Offers wholesale pricing on diamonds, leveraging long-standing relationships with top suppliers to provide value.

Rare Carat

Rare Carat’s pricing advantage comes from operating online with no physical retail overhead and no commissioned sales staff, plus a price-match guarantee on comparable certified stones. Their AI tool scores each diamond’s listed price against market data, which gives buyers a useful reference point. Peter Norman sources diamonds directly and prices without luxury-retail markups, with the added value being original design and bespoke craftsmanship rather than a stone-plus-setting transaction.

Truly Custom or only customized?

Peter Norman

Specializes in creating unique pieces tailored to individual preferences.

Rare Carat

Rare Carat sells preset and semi-custom styles configured online by metal, prong type and a limited range of setting variations. Fully custom work is possible in some cases, but it is handled remotely and constrained by an e-commerce workflow. There is no equivalent to sitting with a jeweler and working a design from a blank page. At Peter Norman, proportions, finish, stone placement and structure are all specified for that one piece rather than chosen from a menu.

OK to bring your own diamond?

Peter Norman

Encourages clients to bring their own gemstones, whether they’re heirlooms or purchased independently.

Rare Carat

Rare Carat’s model is built around buying a diamond through their platform and pairing it with one of their settings; there is no published service for setting an existing or inherited stone. If you have a diamond you want to keep, or an heirloom you want to redesign, Rare Carat is not the right fit. Peter Norman works with customer-supplied and heirloom diamonds regularly, treating the existing stone as the starting point for a new design.

Natural and lab grown diamonds?

Peter Norman & Rare Carat

Both Peter Norman and Rare Carat offer natural and lab-grown diamonds, with Peter Norman generally offering better pricing due to wholesale options. Additionally, Peter Norman only sells the higher quality GIA diamonds whereas rare Carat also sells the lower quality IGI diamonds. So the lab-grown diamonds from Peter Norman will be better quality and priced.

Rare Carat

Rare Carat lists both natural and lab-grown diamonds across a wide range of shapes and grades, all carrying GIA, IGI or GCAL certification, with lab-grown options prominently featured at lower price points. Peter Norman also offers both natural and lab-grown, and can advise on the practical and long-term differences between them based on what matters most to you.

After-Purchase Service

Peter Norman

Offers comprehensive after-purchase services, including resizing, repolishing, and repairs. Clients can access these services both in-store and remotely, ensuring their jewelry remains in pristine condition. This personalized care underscores their commitment to customer satisfaction.

Peter Norman

Provides standard after-sales services typical of online retailers, such as free insured shipping, a 30-day return policy, and one free resizing within 90 days for rings. While these services are convenient, they may not match the personalized attention offered by boutique jewelers.

peter norman

Rings

Bezel-Set Asscher-Cut Ring in Yellow Gold

Bezel-Set Three Stone Emerald Diamond Engagement Ring

Available in the precious metal of your choice.

Elongated Cushion-Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

Elongated Cushion-Cut Diamond Engagement Ring with Hidden Halo

Emerald-Cut Diamond Ring with Marquise

Emerald-Cut Diamond Ring with Marquise Floral Accents and Diamond Band

Emerald-Cut Diamond Ring with Trapezoid Side Stones

Moval-Cut Diamond Ring with Diamond Details and Diamond Bridge

Available in the precious metal of your choice.

Oval Engagement Ring

Oval-Cut Engagement Ring with a Three-Sided Diamond Band

Round Six Prong Engagement Ring

Round Six Prong Engagement Ring with Floral Prongs and Diamond Band

Toi et Moi Pear Engagement Ring

Two Stone Pear-Shaped Diamond Toi et Moi Ring

Two-Tone Emerald-Cut Solitaire Ring

East-West Emerald-Cut Diamond Engagement Ring with a Platinum Head and Yellow Gold Band

Yellow Gold Oval Diamond Solitaire with Hidden Halo

what our clients say

Reviews

← → 01 /

We had a great experience with Gaelle and Peter who helped us source our diamond and design our engagement ring. They provided amazing advice and were a great resource throughout the whole process. We loved their work and the result and will certainly come back!

Kareem H.
Peter Norman did an amazing job on my engagement ring! My fiancé and I met with him once, and he created a design that matches me perfectly. After talking and seeing his store, we knew he was the perfect fit!

Elise P.
Few things terrify me as much as buyers remorse. Even more so when it involves one of the most important purchases of my life. When I walked into Peter Norman Jewelers, I could feel my anxiety immediately melt away. Peter and his staff are attentive, warm, and highly communicative. They showed me all sorts of options and helped me find a diamond and band that was exactly what I was looking for. Seeing the ring we had designed for the first time took my breath away. I’ve never felt so confident in a purchase. I knew my fiancé would be as excited as I was to wear the ring as I was to put it on her. Peter, thank you so much for your time, your care, and your craftsmanship.

Christopher K.
World-class experience with Peter and his Team, even though I live 1500 miles from Los Angeles! I will recommend every person I know in the market for a ring.

We needed a ring in about two weeks with specific style, stone, cut, and certifications, plus a hectic travel schedule. Instead of saying no, Peter shipped overnight and exceeded every expectation. He communicated clearly, sent photos, offered advice, and was professional and supportive. The ring arrived on time and turned out incredible. When I needed a resize, I dropped it off in LA, and he shipped it back within five days. This was one of the best customer experiences I’ve ever had. Could not endorse Peter enough!

Justin G.
I initially bought my engagement ring at Brilliant Earth but when I received it, I was not sure about it. Peter showed me the ring under magnification and showed me evidence it was just a mass-produced ring. And my diamond… when I saw it by itself I thought it was fine, but when Peter showed me my Brilliant Earth diamond beside some quality(not super expensive) diamonds from his rings…. it was like looking at yellow vs white. Ring returned, the new ring was commissioned with Peter Norman. I paid more… but now have a hand-crafted ring, with a truly brilliant, well-cut diamond.”

Michael Jamieson
I was at first concerned about buying a ring from across the country, but the Google reviews were so good, and a chat with peter gave me the confidence to proceed. So happy I did, a fantastic result for me, I love my ring!

Jean Anne Booth
I had my vintage Chanel necklace resized here and they were very Covid-safe, removed the links and even cleaned my necklace for a very low price! I will definitely give them my business again.

Jocelyn B.
I am so beyond in love with my ring. My fiance said nothing but amazing things about working with Peter to create the custom ring of my dreams. We will most certainly be returning for our wedding bands and will be recommending Peter and his team to friends and family!

Zoe S.
I get so many compliments on my ring- it’s beautiful, it’s unique, it’s dainty but stunning! I also love the Peter Norman sales team. I stop by regularly with my Frenchie Lulu. They give her treats and belly rubs while my rings gets a complimentary cleaning. Stop by and take a look!

Bettina H.

Peter NormanvsRare Carat