The Pros and Cons of Different Diamond Shapes

Published
Categorized as Blog
diamond cuts
diamond cuts

Are you wondering which diamond cut is right for you? Are you seeking to learn the differences between diamond shapes to find the perfect one for your engagement ring?

You might be asking:

  • Which cut offers the most sparkle?
  • Which one looks the biggest?
  • What’s the best option for my budget?
  • Or maybe you’re searching for a unique, timeless design.

In this article we break down the pros and cons of each popular diamond cut, helping you make an informed decision based on your specific needs and preferences. Let’s explore the options together and discover the ideal diamond for you.

Round Cut Diamond

The round-cut diamond is celebrated for its exceptional brilliance and timeless appeal, making it a top choice for engagement rings. Its 58 precisely cut facets maximize light reflection, creating a dazzling sparkle that captures attention and admiration.

Pros:

  • Exceptional brilliance and sparkle
  • Versatile and stunning in any setting, from classic solitaires to vintage-inspired designs
  • Durable with rounded edges, less prone to chipping, ideal for active lifestyles and everyday wear

Cons:

  • More expensive due to popularity and intricate cutting process
  • Cutting requires removing more of the rough stone, increasing production costs and waste

Suited To:

  • Those seeking maximum sparkle and brilliance
  • Individuals with active lifestyles requiring a durable diamond
  • Anyone wanting a versatile diamond that complements various settings and styles

Oval Cut

The oval cut diamond, a close contender in popularity to the round cut, offers stunning brilliance and unique charm. Its elongated shape enhances the appearance of the finger, making it look more slender and graceful, and it often appears larger than a round diamond of the same carat weight.

Pros:

  • Stunning brilliance and unique charm
  • Elongated shape enhances the appearance of the finger
  • Often appears larger than round diamonds of the same carat weight
  • Versatile in ring settings, can be set vertically or horizontally
  • Smooth, rounded edges reduce the risk of chipping
  • Durable for everyday wear

Cons:

  • Potential for a “bowtie effect,” a shadow across the center of the stone
  • Visibility of the bowtie effect varies from diamond to diamond

Suited To:

  • Those seeking a diamond that enhances finger length and gracefulness
  • Individuals looking for a versatile diamond that can be creatively set
  • Buyers wanting a substantial presence without increasing carat weight

Cushion Cut

The cushion cut diamond, experiencing a resurgence in popularity, is prized for its vintage charm and elegant appeal. Shaped like a cushion, it can be either square or rectangular with rounded edges that provide additional protection against chipping.

Pros:

  • Vintage charm and elegant appeal
  • Rounded edges provide additional protection against chipping
  • Larger facets produce excellent fire, displaying striking flashes of color
  • Particularly beneficial for colored diamonds, enhancing their natural hue and vibrancy
  • Versatile shape options, available in square or rectangular profiles
  • Durable and suitable for everyday wear

Cons:

  • Does not exhibit the same level of brilliance as round or oval cuts
  • Often appears smaller when viewed from above compared to other cuts of the same carat weight due to its deeper cut

Suited To:

  • Those seeking a diamond with vintage allure and elegant appeal
  • Individuals who appreciate extra sparkle and flashes of color
  • Buyers looking for a versatile and durable diamond suitable for everyday wear

Princess Cut

And then arrives the princess! The princess-cut diamond is an excellent option for those seeking a stunning square shape. Known for its brilliant cut, the princess cut offers exceptional sparkle and can effectively hide flaws within the diamond, ensuring a dazzling appearance.

Pros:

  • Exceptional sparkle and brilliance
  • Square shape with a modern, geometric appeal
  • Clean lines and symmetrical form, ideal for contemporary settings
  • Can effectively hide flaws within the diamond

Cons:

  • Sharp corners are prone to chipping
  • Requires a protective setting, such as a bezel or prong, to enhance durability

Suited To:

  • Those seeking a modern, square-shaped diamond
  • Individuals wanting a diamond with exceptional sparkle and brilliance
  • Buyers looking for a contemporary and elegant piece of jewelry

Pear Cut

For those seeking a blend of traditional elegance and unique style, pear-shaped diamonds are an excellent choice. These stones are both brilliant and elongating, often appearing larger than many other cuts when viewed from above and can be more affordable compared to the more popular diamond cuts.

Pros:

  • Blend of traditional elegance and unique style
  • Brilliant and elongating appearance, often looking larger than other cuts of the same carat weight
  • Generally more affordable compared to popular diamond cuts

Cons:

  • Potential for a “bowtie effect,” a shadow across the center of the stone
  • Pointed tip is vulnerable to chipping and requires protection from a prong setting
  • Importance of symmetry for maximum visual appeal and brilliance

Suited To:

  • Those seeking a diamond with both traditional elegance and a distinctive look
  • Individuals looking for a larger appearance without increasing carat size
  • Budget-conscious buyers wanting a beautiful yet affordable diamond

Marquise-Cut

Marquise-cut diamonds, elongated with a point at each end, are a budget-friendly option. This modified-brilliant cut makes the wearer’s finger appear slender and the diamond face up larger than other styles.

Pros:

  • Budget-friendly option
  • Elongated shape makes the finger appear slender
  • Appears larger than other cuts of the same carat weight

Cons:

  • Exhibits a “bowtie effect,” a shadow across the center of the stone
  • Tapered points can chip easily and require protection
  • Requires a well-cut diamond with good symmetry and length-to-width ratio

Suited To:

  • Those seeking a budget-friendly diamond option
  • Individuals wanting a diamond that elongates the appearance of their finger
  • Buyers looking for a diamond that appears larger without increasing carat size

Emerald Cut

If you aren’t seeking a diamond with the flashiness of a brilliant cut, you might opt for a step-cut stone, such as an emerald. Elongating and sophisticated, emerald cuts can face up larger than other shapes and have long parallel facets that reflect broad flashes of light instead of overall sparkle.

Pros:

  • Elongating and sophisticated appearance
  • Faces up larger than other shapes
  • Long parallel facets reflect broad flashes of light
  • Flattened corners reduce the likelihood of snagging

Cons:

  • Prone to showing inclusions, requiring a high clarity grade
  • Lacks the overall sparkle of brilliant cuts

Suited To:

  • Those seeking a diamond with an elegant, sophisticated look
  • Individuals preferring broad flashes of light over continuous sparkle
  • Buyers wanting a diamond that faces up larger than its carat weight

Asscher Cut

The Asscher cut is a stunning step-cut diamond known for its broad flashes of light and captivating vintage appeal, reminiscent of the Art Deco era. Square in shape with flattened corners, it shares similarities with the emerald cut, offering a unique and sophisticated look.

Pros:

  • Broad flashes of light thanks to step-cut faceting
  • Captivating vintage appeal with a touch of historical allure
  • Unique and sophisticated square shape with flattened corners

Cons:

  • Does not hide inclusions as well as other cuts, requiring a high clarity grade
  • Can appear smaller face-up than other cuts of the same carat weight due to concentrated depth

Suited To:

  • Those seeking a diamond with classic elegance and vintage charm
  • Individuals who appreciate the hall-of-mirrors effect and broad light reflections
  • Buyers wanting a unique and sophisticated diamond with historical appeal

Radiant Cut Diamonds

Radiant cut diamonds are known for their unique blend of brilliance and modern appeal, featuring a rectangular or square shape with cropped corners. Combining elements of both round and emerald cuts, they have 70 facets that reflect light beautifully, creating a dazzling sparkle.

Pros:

  • Unique blend of brilliance and modern appeal
  • 70 facets create a dazzling sparkle
  • Effectively hides inclusions, making it a practical choice for clarity
  • Appears larger than other cuts of the same carat weight

Cons:

  • Sharp corners can be prone to chipping, requiring a protective setting

Suited To:

  • Those seeking exceptional brilliance with a contemporary look
  • Individuals looking for a diamond that effectively hides inclusions
  • Buyers wanting a diamond that appears larger without increasing carat size

Ten different diamond types include round, princess, cushion, emerald, Asscher, marquise, oval, radiant, pear, and heart. Each type has distinct features and appeal, catering to a wide range of preferences. Understanding these types helps in selecting the perfect diamond to match personal style and requirements.

Diamond shapes include round, princess, cushion, emerald, Asscher, marquise, oval, radiant, pear, and heart. Each shape offers a unique aesthetic and can influence the diamond’s sparkle and overall appearance. Choosing the right shape is crucial for achieving the desired look and feel.

The round-cut diamond gives the most sparkle due to its 58 facets that maximize light reflection. This cut is celebrated for its brilliance and timeless appeal, making it a top choice for engagement rings. Its symmetrical design ensures stunning sparkle in any setting.

As of 2024, oval diamonds are trending. They are favored for their elegant, elongated shape that enhances the finger’s appearance and offers a unique blend of classic and modern appeal. The oval cut also appears larger than round diamonds of the same carat weight, adding to its popularity.

Fancy diamond shapes include any shape other than round, such as princess, cushion, and marquise. These shapes offer distinctive looks that stand out from traditional round diamonds. Fancy shapes are perfect for those seeking unique and personalized jewelry designs.

The emerald cut is often considered the classiest diamond cut. Its step-cut facets and elongated shape exude sophistication and elegance. This cut is less flashy but offers a refined look with broad, dramatic flashes of light.

The marquise cut is among the least popular diamond shapes. Its elongated, boat-like shape can be less appealing to some due to its distinctive appearance and the potential for a “bowtie” effect. Despite this, it can create a unique, bold look for the right wearer.

Beauty is subjective, but many consider the oval cut to be one of the most beautiful shapes. Its elongated form and brilliant facets provide a stunning, elegant appearance. This shape also has the advantage of looking larger than its actual carat weight.

The round brilliant cut is the most brilliant diamond shape. With its 58 facets, it is engineered to maximize light reflection and sparkle. This makes it the most popular choice for those seeking maximum brilliance and fire in their diamond.

The most inexpensive diamond shape is often the cushion cut. This shape is typically less costly due to its lower demand and the efficiency in cutting it from rough diamonds. Despite its affordability, the cushion cut offers a unique blend of vintage charm and modern elegance.

The most popular diamond cut in 2024 is the oval cut. Its rise in popularity is due to its unique shape that elongates the finger and provides a substantial presence. The oval cut is versatile and fits well with various ring settings.

The pear cut is considered one of the most unique diamond shapes. Its teardrop form combines the best features of round and marquise cuts, offering a distinctive and elegant look. This shape also provides an elongating effect on the finger.

Round-cut diamonds tend to hold their value the best. Their timeless appeal and high demand ensure that they retain resale value over time. The round cut is also the most popular, contributing to its sustained value.

The round brilliant cut is generally the most expensive diamond shape. Its higher cost is due to its popularity and the intricate cutting process that maximizes its brilliance. The cutting process also involves more waste, increasing the overall cost.

The emerald cut sparkles the least among popular diamond cuts. Its step-cut facets produce broad flashes of light rather than the continuous sparkle seen in brilliant cuts. This gives it a more understated, elegant appearance.

The oval cut diamond often looks the biggest compared to other shapes of the same carat weight. Its elongated shape maximizes surface area, giving it a larger appearance. This makes it an excellent choice for those wanting a more substantial look without increasing carat size.

By Peter Norman

Peter Norman is one of Los Angeles’ most celebrated wedding jewelers, with his custom-made engagement rings and wedding bands taking center place in thousands of weddings over the last 40 years. Each engagement ring is custom designed, built to order, and can suit any budget: from the simply elegant 1-carat solitaires to the exquisite pieces fit for (and sometimes purchased by) royalty.

en_USEN